Value Creation vs Job Preservation
There are two ends of the spectrum of how people look at their work and the type of culture a company operates in: value creation on one end and job preservation on the other (in between is “just getting paid”).
Job preservation
I find people and environments that are oriented towards job preservation to be exhausting.
The people who think like this only do work that aids in preserving their job (including teeing up their next promotion). They don’t just do the things that need to get done; they do it if it helps them preserve their job.
Environments that orient towards job preservation are also exhausting. A lot of effort goes into proving why their job should be preserved instead of creating value. Orgs are stuck in a loop of struggle to deliver features that should be table stakes because the focus is on job preservation, not value creation.
When people talk about “politics”, this is usually what they mean: job preservation. People who are very focused on job preservation also tend to bring a lot of ego (a big part of job preservation is fluffing themselves up). It’s really draining working with people who are focused on job preservation.
(I’ve also written a bit about this before as well: Beware the Complexity Merchants)
Value creation
On the other end is value creation. For me, this feels energizing; there’s a clear reason and a mission. Working 12x7 doesn’t feel draining because the line from the work to the value created is so direct.
People that operate in this mode don’t ask “what’s in it for me?”, “is this billable?” (except to follow process), “is it assigned to me?”. Something of value needs to get done? They do it because they place value creation above all else.
In an organization that is oriented for value creation, autonomy is easy and natural because the direction towards value is clearly communicated and everyone can see how more value gets created and how their work contributes to that value. When more value gets created, everyone wins; no one stops and thinks about getting more credit because everyone can see where value originates. No one has to guess what the right action or the right decision is: it’s the one that creates more value.
Brian Chesky’s Don’t Fuck Up the Culture says that “culture is simply a shared way of doing something with passion.” I think a big piece of that is alignment on the value being created. He follows: “When the culture is strong, you can trust everyone to do the right thing. People can be independent and autonomous.” That works because people understand where the value is being created; autonomy follows from alignment.
People and teams that operate in value creation mode can often disagree on how value gets created, but they rarely let job preservation get in the way.
When one becomes the other
Both people and companies can oscillate from one to the other (companies more than people, I think).
This is what Thiel meant by “don’t fuck up the culture”. Don’t become a company where teams lose the line of sight to value and focus instead on job preservation.
When a company or team goes from value creation mode to job preservation mode, organizational alignment is lost; everyone is looking out for themselves instead of trying to figure out how they add value to the whole.
That’s why culture, alignment, and communication are so important; because these are what effect value creation mode.
Making Startups Powerful - Paul Graham
Paul Graham has a great essay on this that spells out value creation much more explicitly:
The reason Paypal grew so fast was that it helped users make money. Few things make you more powerful than that. When you help users make money, they’re (a) quick to adopt your product and (b) will pay a lot for it. So your revenues grow doubly fast. Most of the most successful companies we’ve funded help their users to make money, as does YC itself.
Playing the long game makes you more powerful, because most other people you encounter won’t be. Most startups competing with you will be run by opportunists hoping to be acquired. Most big companies you deal with will be run by executives who don’t expect to be there for more than a few years and are only thinking about this quarter’s numbers.
Being generous makes you more powerful. As Tim O’Reilly said, you should create more value than you capture. Many hard-headed business types would write this off as idealistic hippy stuff, but in fact this is the route to becoming really rich. Squeezing every last penny out of customers is a distraction. It gets you 2x returns at most. Whereas discovering some new thing you could make for them could easily get you 10x or 100x returns. They’re two different ways of looking at the world, and the O’Reilly way makes more, for those who can do it.
A great read for anyone thinking about a startup…or enterprises adapting to this new world when anyone can vibe code software; organizational job preservation may not be a sustainable strategy.
It’s a lot more fun working in value creation mode and the outcome is generally more rewarding (not always monetary).
Be careful when you hire; especially in a small team and startups. Hiring someone that is focused on job preservation instead of value creation can create some bad vibes.
It’s taken me this long to figure out why some teams and people have “good vibes”. It’s because the people and org are fully aligned on value creation and no one cares about job preservation.
I hope this helps you see things more clearly.
(Aside: I think this is why vibe-coding can also feel draining after a while. You can create anything you want with ease, but much of it doesn’t have value.)